| 7 | Nelson v Accrington | The Property Shop Arena, Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 2021 |
| 6 | Nelson v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 1900 |
| 6 | Nelson (1) v Accrington | Seedhill, Nelson | 1902 |
| 6 | Nelson v Colne | Seedhill, Nelson | 1944 |
| 6 | Nelson v Rishton | Blackburn Road, Rishton | 1944 |
| 6 | Nelson v Lowerhouse | Liverpool Road, Lowerhouse | 1958 |
| 6 | Nelson v Rishton | Blackburn Road, Rishton | 1981 |
| 6 | Nelson v Enfield | Dill Hall Lane, Enfield | 1982 |
| 6 | Nelson v Rochdale | Redbrook, Rochdale | 2018 |
| 6 | Nelson v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 2022 |
| 6 | Nelson v Colne | Seedhill, Nelson | 2022 |
| 6 | Nelson v Great Harwood | Evolve Document Solutions Cliffe Park, Great Harwood | 2023 |
| 5 | Nelson v Rawtenstall | The Worswick Memorial Ground, Rawtenstall | 1894 |
| 5 | Nelson v Colne | Seedhill, Nelson | 1896 |
| 5 | Nelson v Rawtenstall | The Worswick Memorial Ground, Rawtenstall | 1897 |
| 5 | Nelson v Lowerhouse | Seedhill, Nelson | 1899 |
| 5 | Nelson (1) v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 1899 |
| 5 | Nelson (1) v Accrington | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1902 |
| 5 | Nelson v Burnley | Seedhill, Nelson | 1906 |
| 5 | Nelson v Colne | Seedhill, Nelson | 1909 |
| 5 | Nelson v Rawtenstall | Seedhill, Nelson | 1914 |
| 5 | Nelson v Todmorden | Centre Vale, Todmorden | 1914 |
| 5 | Nelson v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 1915 |
| 5 | Nelson v Enfield | Dill Hall Lane, Enfield | 1921 |
| 5 | Nelson v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 1932 |
| 5 | Nelson v Accrington | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1939 |
| 5 | Nelson v Enfield | Dill Hall Lane, Enfield | 1941 |
| 5 | Nelson v East Lancashire | Seedhill, Nelson | 1951 |
| 5 | Nelson v Ramsbottom | Acre Bottom, Ramsbottom | 1957 |
| 5 | Nelson v Ramsbottom | Seedhill, Nelson | 1957 |
| 5 | Nelson v Haslingden | Bentgate, Haslingden | 1958 |
| 5 | Nelson v East Lancashire | Alexandra Meadows, Blackburn | 1959 |
| 5 | Nelson v Colne | The Horsfield, Colne | 1961 |
| 5 | Nelson v Accrington | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1974 |
| 5 | Nelson v Ramsbottom | Seedhill, Nelson | 1976 |
| 5 | Nelson v Church | Seedhill, Nelson | 1980 |
| 5 | Nelson v Accrington | Thorneyholme Road, Accrington | 1982 |
| 5 | Nelson v Ramsbottom | Seedhill, Nelson | 1983 |
| 5 | Nelson v Accrington | Seedhill, Nelson | 1988 |
| 5 | Nelson v Enfield | Seedhill, Nelson | 1991 |
| 5 | Nelson v Bacup | Lanehead, Bacup | 2001 |
| 5 | Nelson v Bacup | Lanehead, Bacup | 2007 |
| 5 | Nelson v Church | Blackburn Road, Oswaldtwistle | 2023 |
