| Extras |
| 47 | Old Merchant Taylors v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2001 |
| 45 | Old Eastbournians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Eastbourne College Ground, Eastbourne | 2017 |
| 44 | Shrewsbury Saracens v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2023 |
| 39 | Old Merchant Taylors v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2021 |
| 36 | Old Cranleighans v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2018 |
| 34 | Bradfield Waifs v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2001 |
| 34 | Downside Wanderers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2002 |
| 33 | Old Cholmeleians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2015 |
| 32 | Rugby Meteors v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 1987 |
| 30 | Old Merchant Taylors v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 1990 |
| 30 | Harrow Wanderers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Harrow School Cricket Ground, Harrow-on-the-Hill | 2002 |
| 30 | Charterhouse Friars v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2005 |
| 29 | St Edward's Martyrs v Sherborne Pilgrims | St Edward's School Ground, Oxford | 2007 |
| 29 | Bradfield Waifs v Sherborne Pilgrims | Bradfield College, Reading | 2012 |
| 29 | Uppingham Rovers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Upper Field, Uppingham School | 2016 |
| 29 | Old Cheltonians v Sherborne Pilgrims | College Ground, Cheltenham | 2018 |
| 29 | Old Brightonians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2022 |
| 27 | Old Malvernians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 2008 |
| 26 | Old Tonbridgians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Tonbridge School Ground, Tonbridge | 2001 |
| 26 | Haileybury Hermits v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2017 |
| 25 | Old Malvernians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 2024 |
| 25 | St Edward's Martyrs v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2025 |
| 24 | Harrow Wanderers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 1985 |
| 24 | Old Wellingtonians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Wellington College, Crowthorne | 1991 |
| 24 | Downside Wanderers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Downside School, Stratton-on-the-Fosse | 1992 |
| 23 | Uppingham Rovers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Middle Field Pitch 1, Uppingham School | 1987 |
| 23 | Haileybury Hermits v Sherborne Pilgrims | Haileybury College Ground, Hertford | 1996 |
| 23 | Old Brightonians v Sherborne Pilgrims | Brighton College Ground, Brighton | 2003 |
| 22 | Radley Rangers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Radley College Bigside Ground, Abingdon | 1999 |
| 22 | Bradfield Waifs v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2008 |
| 22 | Radley Rangers v Sherborne Pilgrims | Sherborne School, Sherborne | 2010 |
| 22 | Marlborough Blues v Sherborne Pilgrims | Marlborough College Ground, Marlborough | 2010 |
