| 7 | MJ Stewart | Surrey v Northamptonshire | County Ground, Northampton | 1957 | f21760 |
| 7 | AS Brown | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1966 | f26396 |
| 7 | R Clarke | Warwickshire v Lancashire | Aigburth, Liverpool | 2011 | f53305 |
| 6 | FA Tarrant | Middlesex v Essex | County Ground, Leyton | 1906 | f6978 |
| 6 | WR Hammond | Gloucestershire v Surrey | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1928 | f12495 |
| 6 | WR Hammond | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire | Ashley Down Ground, Bristol | 1933 | f14314 |
| 6 | EP Robinson | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | Park Avenue Cricket Ground, Bradford | 1938 | f16319 |
| 6 | KJ Grieves | Lancashire v Sussex | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1951 | f19219 |
| 6 | JD Clay | Nottinghamshire v Derbyshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1957 | f21864 |
| 6 | RG Broadbent | Worcestershire v Glamorgan | War Memorial Ground, Amblecote | 1960 | f23300 |
| 6 | MJK Smith | Warwickshire v Leicestershire | Coventry Road, Hinckley | 1962 | f24275 |
| 6 | M Bissex | Gloucestershire v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1968 | f27375 |
| 6 | JD Carr | Middlesex v Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1995 | f41722 |
| 6 | GP Thorpe | Surrey v Kent | The Foster's Oval, Kennington | 1998 | f43726 |
| 6 | T Kohler-Cadmore | Yorkshire v Kent | Spitfire Ground, St Lawrence, Canterbury | 2019 | f59466 |
| 6 | TT Bresnan | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | Emerald Headingley Cricket Stadium, Leeds | 2021 | f60507 |
| 6 | OJD Pope | Surrey v Hampshire | The Kia Oval, Kennington | 2024 | f62243 |
| 5 | JR Painter | Gloucestershire v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1891 | f3607 |
| 5 | FWD Quinton | Hampshire v Yorkshire | St George's Road, Harrogate | 1896 | f4544 |
| 5 | AG Paul | Lancashire v Derbyshire | County Ground, Derby | 1897 | f4636 |
| 5 | J Tunnicliffe | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | Headingley, Leeds | 1897 | f4656 |
| 5 | R Abel | Surrey v Hampshire | United Services Ground, Portsmouth | 1898 | f4939 |
| 5 | J Tunnicliffe | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | Grace Road, Leicester | 1900 | f5338 |
| 5 | J Tunnicliffe | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | North Marine Road, Scarborough | 1901 | f5625 |
| 5 | J Daniell | Somerset v Kent | County Ground, Taunton | 1901 | f5691 |
| 5 | AO Jones | Nottinghamshire v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1907 | f7140 |
| 5 | G Gunn | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1909 | f7673 |
| 5 | LC Braund | Somerset v Worcestershire | County Ground, Taunton | 1909 | f7762 |
| 5 | GN Foster | Worcestershire v Hampshire | County Ground, Southampton | 1911 | f8338 |
| 5 | CP Mead | Hampshire v Middlesex | United Services Ground, Portsmouth | 1912 | f8577 |
| 5 | H Whitehead | Leicestershire v Sussex | Aylestone Road, Leicester | 1912 | f8604 |
| 5 | GM Lee | Nottinghamshire v Hampshire | County Ground, Southampton | 1913 | f8853 |
| 5 | G Brown | Hampshire v Somerset | Recreation Ground, Bath | 1914 | f9122 |
| 5 | GA Stannard | Sussex v Gloucestershire | Spa Ground, Gloucester | 1919 | f9341 |
| 5 | FH Gillingham | Essex v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1919 | f9342 |
| 5 | CJB Wood | Leicestershire v Warwickshire | Ashby Road, Hinckley | 1919 | f9408 |
| 5 | WE Astill | Leicestershire v Somerset | Clarence Park, Weston-super-Mare | 1920 | f9758 |
| 5 | RK Tyldesley | Lancashire v Hampshire | Aigburth, Liverpool | 1921 | f9876 |
| 5 | MS Nichols | Essex v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1926 | f11542 |
| 5 | FE Woolley | Kent v Middlesex | The Rectory Field, Blackheath | 1926 | f11699 |
| 5 | WE Bates | Glamorgan v Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1928 | f12249 |
| 5 | JS Nicholson | Northamptonshire v Worcestershire | Tipton Road, Dudley | 1928 | f12265 |
| 5 | NE Haig | Middlesex v Nottinghamshire | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1928 | f12439 |
| 5 | AH Bakewell | Northamptonshire v Essex | County Ground, Leyton | 1928 | f12451 |
| 5 | GE Hunt | Somerset v Hampshire | Clarence Park, Weston-super-Mare | 1928 | f12491 |
| 5 | G Brown | Hampshire v Kent | United Services Ground, Portsmouth | 1932 | f13886 |
| 5 | AF Wensley | Sussex v Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1932 | f13912 |
| 5 | AB Sellers | Yorkshire v Essex | County Ground, Leyton | 1933 | f14312 |
| 5 | AW Carr | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1933 | f14352 |
| 5 | BH Lyon | Gloucestershire v Leicestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1933 | f14384 |
| 5 | AF Wensley | Sussex v Surrey | Cricket Field Road, Horsham | 1934 | f14614 |
| 5 | FE Woolley | Kent v Hampshire | St Lawrence Ground, Canterbury | 1936 | f15502 |
| 5 | FH Vigar | Essex v Northamptonshire | Old County Ground, Brentwood | 1946 | f17162 |
| 5 | FH Vigar | Essex v Middlesex | Chalkwell Park, Westcliff-on-Sea | 1946 | f17229 |
| 5 | LF Outschoorn | Worcestershire v Derbyshire | Chester Road North, Kidderminster | 1948 | f18019 |
| 5 | JG Langridge | Sussex v Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1950 | f18645 |
| 5 | KJ Grieves | Lancashire v Glamorgan | Stanley Park, Blackpool | 1950 | f18857 |
| 5 | FH Vigar | Essex v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1951 | f19131 |
| 5 | AE Fagg | Kent v Hampshire | County Ground, Southampton | 1952 | f19570 |
| 5 | GAR Lock | Surrey v Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1953 | f20007 |
| 5 | KJ Grieves | Lancashire v Gloucestershire | Ashley Down Ground, Bristol | 1954 | f20568 |
| 5 | WS Surridge | Surrey v Lancashire | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1955 | f20855 |
| 5 | ASM Oakman | Sussex v Glamorgan | The Manor Sports Ground, Worthing | 1958 | f22347 |
| 5 | DJ Insole | Essex v Lancashire | Stanley Park, Blackpool | 1958 | f22451 |
| 5 | PM Walker | Glamorgan v Leicestershire | St Helen's, Swansea | 1960 | f23155 |
| 5 | C Lee | Derbyshire v Lancashire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1960 | f23255 |
| 5 | DC Morgan | Derbyshire v Glamorgan | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1960 | f23424 |
| 5 | PM Walker | Glamorgan v Derbyshire | Queen's Park, Chesterfield | 1961 | f23716 |
| 5 | PM Walker | Glamorgan v Nottinghamshire | Rodney Parade, Newport | 1961 | f23746 |
| 5 | MJK Smith | Warwickshire v Glamorgan | St Helen's, Swansea | 1961 | f23804 |
| 5 | ASM Oakman | Sussex v Lancashire | Central Recreation Ground, Hastings | 1961 | f23840 |
| 5 | RL Pratt | Leicestershire v Derbyshire | Grace Road, Leicester | 1961 | f23919 |
| 5 | JM Prodger | Kent v Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1961 | f23946 |
| 5 | G Hughes | Glamorgan v Essex | St Helen's, Swansea | 1964 | f25246 |
| 5 | RGA Headley | Worcestershire v Kent | Hesketh Park, Dartford | 1964 | f25248 |
| 5 | MR Hallam | Leicestershire v Northamptonshire | Grace Road, Leicester | 1964 | f25340 |
| 5 | JM Prodger | Kent v Lancashire | Stanley Park, Blackpool | 1964 | f25431 |
| 5 | AGE Ealham | Kent v Gloucestershire | Cheriton Road Sports Ground, Folkestone | 1966 | f26350 |
| 5 | RGA Headley | Worcestershire v Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1967 | f26926 |
| 5 | Mushtaq Mohammad | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | Baker Perkins Sports Ground, Peterborough | 1968 | f27348 |
| 5 | PJ Robinson | Somerset v Lancashire | Clarence Park, Weston-super-Mare | 1968 | f27393 |
| 5 | D Wilson | Yorkshire v Surrey | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1969 | f27849 |
| 5 | RC Davis | Glamorgan v Northamptonshire | Sophia Gardens, Cardiff | 1970 | f28377 |
| 5 | PM Walker | Glamorgan v Derbyshire | St Helen's, Swansea | 1970 | f28389 |
| 5 | JF Steele | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1971 | f28708 |
| 5 | RG Lumb | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | Acklam Park, Middlesbrough | 1972 | f29133 |
| 5 | BA Richards | Hampshire v Gloucestershire | Wagon Works Ground, Gloucester | 1972 | f29192 |
| 5 | GA Greenidge | Sussex v Glamorgan | County Ground, Hove | 1975 | f30683 |
| 5 | RA Woolmer | Kent v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1976 | f31068 |
| 5 | PB Clift | Leicestershire v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 1976 | f31196 |
| 5 | JA Hopkins | Glamorgan v Worcestershire | Sophia Gardens, Cardiff | 1976 | f31231 |
| 5 | CS Cowdrey | Kent v Sussex | County Ground, Hove | 1982 | f34181 |
| 5 | GA Gooch | Essex v Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1982 | f34211 |
| 5 | RJ Bailey | Northamptonshire v Worcestershire | County Ground, Northampton | 1986 | f36390 |
| 5 | CS Cowdrey | Kent v Warwickshire | Cheriton Road Sports Ground, Folkestone | 1986 | f36555 |
| 5 | RC Ontong | Glamorgan v Yorkshire | Sophia Gardens, Cardiff | 1987 | f36993 |
| 5 | DW Randall | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 1987 | f37070 |
| 5 | AC Storie | Warwickshire v Leicestershire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1988 | f37665 |
| 5 | GA Hick | Worcestershire v Lancashire | Old Trafford, Manchester | 1989 | f38192 |
| 5 | VP Terry | Hampshire v Warwickshire | Dean Park, Bournemouth | 1989 | f38232 |
| 5 | RP Davis | Warwickshire v Somerset | County Ground, Taunton | 1994 | f41103 |
| 5 | MCJ Ball | Gloucestershire v Yorkshire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 1994 | f41185 |
| 5 | NV Knight | Essex v Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 1994 | f41190 |
| 5 | MJ Di Venuto | Derbyshire v Durham | Riverside Ground, Chester-le-Street | 2001 | f45972 |
| 5 | GA Hick | Worcestershire v Essex | The Ford County Ground, Chelmsford | 2005 | f48677 |
| 5 | Azhar Mahmood | Surrey v Worcestershire | The Brit Oval, Kennington | 2006 | f49386 |
| 5 | RE Watkins | Glamorgan v Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 2006 | f49461 |
| 5 | TR Birt | Derbyshire v Northamptonshire | County Ground, Northampton | 2007 | f50081 |
| 5 | ME Trescothick | Somerset v Gloucestershire | County Ground, Bristol | 2007 | f50106 |
| 5 | M van Jaarsveld | Kent v Warwickshire | Edgbaston, Birmingham | 2007 | f50176 |
| 5 | NJ Edwards | Nottinghamshire v Kent | Trent Bridge, Nottingham | 2010 | f52383 |
| 5 | ME Trescothick | Somerset v Lancashire | Aigburth, Liverpool | 2011 | f53179 |
| 5 | R Clarke | Warwickshire v Durham | Emirates Durham International Cricket Ground, Chester-le-Street | 2012 | f54061 |
| 5 | ME Trescothick | Somerset v Nottinghamshire | County Ground, Taunton | 2012 | f54119 |
| 5 | ME Trescothick | Somerset v Sussex | The PROBIZ County Ground, Hove | 2012 | f54154 |
| 5 | ME Trescothick | Somerset v Middlesex | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 2013 | f54940 |
| 5 | HZ Finch | Sussex v Worcestershire | County Ground, New Road, Worcester | 2017 | f57971 |
| 5 | JA Simpson | Middlesex v Gloucestershire | College Ground, Cheltenham | 2021 | f60464 |
| 5 | TWM Latham | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | The Kia Oval, Kennington | 2023 | f61646 |
| 5 | JA Leaning | Kent v Nottinghamshire | Spitfire Ground, St Lawrence, Canterbury | 2023 | f61709 |
