| 7 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Merchant Taylors | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2000 |
| 6 | Repton Pilgrims v Shrewsbury Saracens | Shrewsbury School, Shrewsbury | 1977 |
| 6 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Marlborough College Ground, Marlborough | 1979 |
| 5 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Marlborough College Ground, Marlborough | 1977 |
| 5 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1980 |
| 5 | Repton Pilgrims v Charterhouse Friars | Charterhouse School, Godalming | 1991 |
| 5 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Tonbridgians | Tonbridge School Ground, Tonbridge | 2013 |
| 5 | Repton Pilgrims v Stowe Templars | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2015 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Haileybury Hermits | Haileybury College Ground, Hertford | 1970 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Felsted Robins | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1974 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Wykehamists | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1976 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Blundellians | Blundell's School, Tiverton | 1976 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Oundle Rovers | Vincent Square, Westminster | 1985 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Malvernians | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 1989 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Cliftonians | Clifton College Close Ground, Clifton | 1992 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Marlborough College Ground, Marlborough | 1992 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Charterhouse Friars | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1993 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Cliftonians | Clifton College Close Ground, Clifton | 1994 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Shrewsbury Saracens | Shrewsbury School, Shrewsbury | 2017 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Brightonians | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2023 |
| 4 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Wellingtonians | Wellington College, Crowthorne | 2023 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Tonbridgians | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1971 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Cliftonians | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1972 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Wykehamists | Ridding Field, Winchester | 1974 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Malvernians | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 1978 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Lancing Rovers | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1983 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Rugby Meteors | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1984 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Malvernians | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 1985 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Brightonians | Repton School Ground, Repton | 1987 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Eton Ramblers | Vincent Square, Westminster | 1992 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Felsted Robins | Felsted School Ground, Dunmow | 1994 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Wellingtonians | Wellington College, Crowthorne | 1999 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Shrewsbury Saracens | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2002 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Harrow Wanderers | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2003 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Marlborough College Ground, Marlborough | 2005 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Uppingham Rovers | Middle Field Pitch 1, Uppingham School | 2009 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Wykehamists | Ridding Field, Winchester | 2010 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Malvernians | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2010 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Bedfordians | Bedford School Ground, Bedford | 2013 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Eastbournians | Eastbourne College Ground, Eastbourne | 2014 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Bradfield Waifs | Bradfield College, Reading | 2014 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Old Malvernians | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 2016 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Repton School Ground, Repton | 2019 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Marlborough Blues | Marlborough College Ground, Marlborough | 2021 |
| 3 | Repton Pilgrims v Eton Ramblers | Upper Club, Eton College | 2025 |
