| Extras |
| 55 | Old Malvernians v Old Alleynians | Malvern College Ground, Malvern | 2018 |
| 46 | Shrewsbury Saracens v Old Alleynians | Shrewsbury School, Shrewsbury | 2005 |
| 44 | Old Westminsters v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2005 |
| 40 | Old Merchant Taylors v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2012 |
| 32 | Old Cheltonians v Old Alleynians | College Ground, Cheltenham | 2013 |
| 31 | Old Tonbridgians v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2017 |
| 30 | Shrewsbury Saracens v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Trevor Bailey Sports Ground, Dulwich Common | 2016 |
| 30 | Radley Rangers v Old Alleynians | Radley College Bigside Ground, Abingdon | 2025 |
| 29 | Felsted Robins v Old Alleynians | Old Alleynians Ground, Dulwich Common | 2008 |
| 29 | Radley Rangers v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2011 |
| 28 | Old Westminsters v Old Alleynians | Vincent Square, Westminster | 2004 |
| 27 | Old Cheltonians v Old Alleynians | College Ground, Cheltenham | 2007 |
| 26 | Lancing Rovers v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1999 |
| 26 | Old Tonbridgians v Old Alleynians | Tonbridge School Ground, Tonbridge | 2006 |
| 25 | Shrewsbury Saracens v Old Alleynians | Shrewsbury School, Shrewsbury | 1992 |
| 25 | Old Cranleighans v Old Alleynians | Jubilee, Cranleigh School | 2008 |
| 24 | Old Whitgiftians v Old Alleynians | Croham Manor Road, Croydon | 1990 |
| 24 | Eton Ramblers v Old Alleynians | Upper Club, Eton College | 2023 |
| 23 | Old Amplefordians v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1993 |
| 23 | Harrow Wanderers v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2022 |
| 22 | Old Cholmeleians v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1997 |
| 22 | Old Brightonians v Old Alleynians | Spen Cama Memorial Ground, Fulking | 2021 |
| 20 | Charterhouse Friars v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1984 |
| 19 | Eton Ramblers v Old Alleynians | Agar's Plough, Eton College | 1999 |
| 19 | Old Merchant Taylors v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2001 |
| 19 | Radley Rangers v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2007 |
| 18 | Bradfield Waifs v Old Alleynians | Bradfield College, Reading | 1974 |
| 18 | Old Cliftonians v Old Alleynians | Clifton College Close Ground, Clifton | 1993 |
| 18 | Eton Ramblers v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1994 |
| 17 | Old Tonbridgians v Old Alleynians | Tonbridge School Ground, Tonbridge | 1984 |
| 17 | Stowe Templars v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 1988 |
| 17 | Stowe Templars v Old Alleynians | Dulwich College Ground, Dulwich | 2000 |
