| Extras |
| 17 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | St Albans Club, Buenos Aires | 2022/23 |
| 15 | Mexico v Cayman Islands | St George's College Ground North, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 15 | Canada v Cayman Islands | Maple Leaf North-East Ground, King City | 2025 |
| 14 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | St Albans Club, Buenos Aires | 2022/23 |
| 14 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Jimmy Powell Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2025 |
| 13 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Smith Road Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2022 |
| 13 | Canada v Cayman Islands | Maple Leaf North-West Ground, King City | 2025 |
| 12 | Panama v Cayman Islands | White Hill Field, Somerset | 2023/24 |
| 11 | United States of America v Cayman Islands | Jimmy Powell Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2025 |
| 11 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | Maple Leaf North-West Ground, King City | 2025 |
| 10 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Smith Road Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2022 |
| 10 | Panama v Cayman Islands | Hurlingham Club Ground, Buenos Aires | 2022/23 |
| 10 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | National Stadium, Hamilton | 2023/24 |
| 10 | Suriname v Cayman Islands | Hurlingham Club Ground, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 10 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Maple Leaf North-West Ground, King City | 2025 |
| 9 | Canada v Cayman Islands | National Stadium, Hamilton | 2023/24 |
| 9 | Argentina v Cayman Islands | Hurlingham Club Ground, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 7 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | White Hill Field, Somerset | 2019 |
| 7 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Belgrano Athletic Club Ground, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 7 | Brazil v Cayman Islands | St Albans Club, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 7 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | St Albans Club, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 6 | Argentina v Cayman Islands | Belgrano Athletic Club Ground, Buenos Aires | 2022/23 |
| 5 | Canada v Cayman Islands | White Hill Field, Somerset | 2019 |
| 5 | Canada v Cayman Islands | White Hill Field, Somerset | 2019 |
| 5 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Jimmy Powell Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2022 |
| 5 | Canada v Cayman Islands | White Hill Field, Somerset | 2023/24 |
| 5 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | Jimmy Powell Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2025 |
| 5 | Canada v Cayman Islands | Jimmy Powell Oval, George Town, Grand Cayman | 2025 |
| 5 | Bermuda v Cayman Islands | Maple Leaf North-West Ground, King City | 2025 |
| 4 | United States of America v Cayman Islands | National Stadium, Hamilton | 2019 |
| 4 | Panama v Cayman Islands | St George's College Ground North, Buenos Aires | 2024/25 |
| 4 | Bahamas v Cayman Islands | Maple Leaf North-West Ground, King City | 2025 |
