| 1952 | GWA Chubb, NBF Mann, AD Nourse, AMB Rowan, EAB Rowan |
| 1953 | JE Cheetham, WR Endean, DJ McGlew, HJ Tayfield, JE Waddington |
| 1954 | NAT Adcock, GO Rabone, JR Reid, CB van Ryneveld, JHB Waite |
| 1955 | TL Goddard, PS Heine, HJ Keith, RA McLean, PNF Mansell |
| 1956 | ERH Fuller, DJ Lewis, JR Liddle, ARA Murray, VI Smith |
| 1957 | DCS Compton, KJ Funston, PBH May, JB Statham, JH Wardle |
| 1958 | R Benaud, JW Burke, ID Craig, AK Davidson, KD Mackay |
| 1959 | JT Botten, JH Ferrandi, GAS Innes, AH McKinnon, AJ Pithey |
| 1960 | JP Fellows-Smith, GM Griffin, GB Lawrence, JBR Maile, S O'Linn |
| 1961 | A Bacher, JM Cole, WS Farrer, RG Pollock, C Richardson |
| 1962 | JC Alabaster, EJ Barlow, KC Bland, AE Dick, RC Motz |
| 1963 | PR Carlstein, PM Dodds, JT Partridge, PM Pollock, PL van der Merwe |
| 1964 | SF Burke, DT Lindsay, MJ Macaulay, L Morby-Smith, RB Ullyett |
| 1965 | KF Barrington, R Dumbrill, HR Lance, MJK Smith, FJ Titmus |
| 1966 | JS Pressdee, S Strydom, BJ Versfeld, RC White, CP Wilkins |
| 1967 | JH du Preez, GD McKenzie, MJ Procter, RB Simpson, PHJ Trimborn |
| 1968 | RA Gripper, BL Irvine, RK Muzzell, BA Richards, DJ Schonegevel |
| 1969 | AL Biggs, D Gamsy, D Mackay-Coghill, PJ Muzzell, N Rosendorff |
| 1970 | GA Chevalier, AN Connolly, JW Gleeson, AM Short, GLG Watson |
| 1971 | HM Ackerman, PD de Vaal, GP Pfuhl, CEB Rice, VAP van der Bijl |
| 1972 | A Bruyns, MJD Doherty, AW Greig, RH Kaschula, SD Robertson |
| 1973 | SJ Bezuidenhout, BF Davison, VS Greve, RD Jackman, AL Wilmot |
| 1974 | BF Bath, DB Close, PP Henwood, KA McKenzie |
| 1975 | D Bestall, DAG Fletcher, RW Hanley, DL Hobson, PD Swart |
| 1976 | JG Heron, DK Lillee, AJS Smith |
| 1977 | HR Fotheringham, PN Kirsten, DR Neilson, WT Strydom |
| 1978 | AM Ferreira, I Foulkes, GS le Roux, RET Morris |
| 1979 | PB Clift, FJ le Roux, RA le Roux, WK Watson |
| 1980 | DJ Brickett, RV Jennings, AJ Kourie, AJ Lamb |
| 1981 | SJ Cook, KR Cooper, NT Day, L Seeff |
| 1982 | RLS Armitage, VF du Preez, DD Dyer, ST Jefferies, AP Kuiper |
| 1983 | SJ Cook, HR Fotheringham, AI Kallicharran, KS McEwan, RF Pienaar |
| 1984 | ST Clarke, RW Hanley, PN Kirsten, AP Kuiper, RG Pollock, LG Rowe |
| 1985 | ST Clarke, NT Day, HA Page, CEB Rice, EO Simons, M Yachad |
| 1986 | GS le Roux, KS McEwan, KA McKenzie, CG Rackemann, CEB Rice, MD Taylor |
| 1987 | MD Haysman, GS le Roux, KS McEwan, SB Smith, KC Wessels, BJ Whitfield |
| 1988 | DJ Callaghan, RO Estwick, AJ Lamb, CEB Rice, B Roberts, MW Rushmere |
| 1989 | DJ Cullinan, PS de Villiers, KS McEwan, MJR Rindel, EO Simons, EN Trotman |
| 1990 | MW Gatting, AP Kuiper, RJ McCurdy, JN Maguire, RF Pienaar |
| 1991 | T Bosch, SD Jack, BM McMillan, CR Matthews, M Yachad |
| 1992 | WJ Cronje, AC Hudson, MW Pringle, JN Rhodes, KC Wessels |
| 1993 | AA Donald, OD Gibson, O Henry, BC Lara, Waqar Younis |
| 1994 | G Kirsten, MD Marshall, TG Shaw, SK Warne, SR Waugh |
| 1995 | WJ Cronje, PS de Villiers, G Kirsten, MD Marshall, DJ Richardson |
| 1996 | DJ Cullinan, AA Donald, G Kirsten, BM McMillan, SM Pollock |
| 1997 | M Azharuddin, DM Benkenstein, AA Donald, L Klusener, SR Waugh |
| 1998 | MV Boucher, WJ Cronje, AA Donald, SM Pollock, PL Symcox |
| 1999 | DJ Cullinan, HH Gibbs, JH Kallis, L Klusener, JN Rhodes |
| 2000 | MV Boucher, VC Drakes, M Hayward, JH Kallis, KR Rutherford |
| 2001 | N Boje, ND McKenzie, M Ngam, M Ntini, SM Pollock |
| 2002 | PR Adams, S Elworthy, AJ Hall, GC Smith, M van Jaarsveld |
| 2003 | HH Gibbs, M Ntini, SM Pollock, JA Rudolph, GC Smith |
| 2004 | AC Dawson, HH Gibbs, JH Kallis, A Nel, M Ntini |
| 2005 | AB de Villiers, HH Dippenaar, JH Kallis, A Nel, M Ntini |
| 2006 | HM Amla, MV Boucher, M Ntini, AG Prince, DW Steyn |
| 2007 | GH Bodi, PL Harris, JM Kemp, CK Langeveldt, MN van Wyk |
| 2008 | J Botha, D du Preez, JA Morkel, M Morkel, M Zondeki |
| 2009 | W Bossenger, JP Duminy, CW Henderson, I Khan, RE van der Merwe |
| 2010 | DJ Jacobs, R McLaren, AN Petersen, J Theron, TL Tsolekile |
| 2011 | Z de Bruyn, F du Plessis, Imran Tahir, CA Ingram, RJ Peterson |
| 2012 | F Behardien, M de Lange, RE Levi, VD Philander, LL Tsotsobe |
| 2013 | KJ Abbott, H Davids, D Elgar, RK Kleinveldt, CH Morris |
| 2014 | Q de Kock, HG Kuhn, DA Miller, JL Ontong, S van Zyl |
| 2015 | T Bavuma, SC Cook, K Rabada, RR Rossouw, D Wiese |
| 2016 | SSB Magala, DL Piedt, T Shamsi, DJ Vilas, GC Viljoen |
| 2017 | H Klaasen, KA Maharaj, D Olivier, AL Phehlukwayo, D van Niekerk |
| 2018 | CJ Dala, AK Markram, LT Ngidi, JT Smuts, HE van der Dussen |
| 2019 | TB de Bruyn, RR Hendricks, AA Nortje, D Pretorius, S Qeshile |
| 2020 | BE Hendricks, GF Linde, PJ Malan, LL Sipamla, L Wolvaardt |
