Notes
--> The match was scheduled for three days but completed in two.
--> FW Lillywhite equalled his best innings bowling analysis in First-Class Matches in the Gentlemen first innings
--> CG Taylor reached 50 wickets in First-Class Matches when he dismissed , his 2nd wicket in the Players first innings
In this match known as the 'Barn Door Match' the Players defended a wicket of four stumps 36 in. by 12 in., whereas the Gentlemen defended three stumps of normal size (27 in. by 8 in.). Pilch is given out 'hat knocked on wicket' in Scores and Biographies