| 3 | JE Southgate | Wimbledon v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1859 |
| 3 | RK Oliver | Cranleigh v Reigate Priory | Park Lane, Reigate | surrp1886 |
| 3 | SDG Bugler | Weybridge v Cranleigh | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1891 |
| 3 | Himmat Singh | Ashtead v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1904 |
| 3 | BM Broughton | East Molesey v Cranleigh | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1913 |
| 2 | J Broad | Reigate Priory v Esher | Park Lane, Reigate | surrp1853 |
| 2 | CR Campbell | Weybridge v East Molesey | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1855 |
| 2 | NJ Tilley | East Molesey v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1855 |
| 2 | J Webb | Cranleigh v Wimbledon | Church Road, Wimbledon | surrp1856 |
| 2 | JK Maunders | Banstead v Sunbury | Recreation Ground, Banstead | surrp1857 |
| 2 | H Aravinthan | Cranleigh v Ashtead | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1858 |
| 2 | RS Patel | East Molesey v Wimbledon | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1859 |
| 2 | NA Sowter | Reigate Priory v Normandy | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1861 |
| 2 | S Holland | Reigate Priory v Normandy | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1861 |
| 2 | BBA Geddes | East Molesey v Ashtead | Woodfield Lane, Ashtead | surrp1862 |
| 2 | K Smith | Cranleigh v Sunbury | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1865 |
| 2 | R Soni | Cranleigh v Sunbury | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1865 |
| 2 | SDJ Burge | Banstead v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1866 |
| 2 | W Edwards | Ashtead v Esher | New Road, Esher | surrp1867 |
| 2 | V Venkateswaran | Wimbledon v Normandy | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1868 |
| 2 | AEC Dahl | Weybridge v Reigate Priory | Park Lane, Reigate | surrp1869 |
| 2 | RK Oliver | Weybridge v Reigate Priory | Park Lane, Reigate | surrp1869 |
| 2 | P Mann | Sunbury v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1873 |
| 2 | JME Barrs | Sunbury v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1873 |
| 2 | J Thompson | Esher v Cranleigh | New Road, Esher | surrp1875 |
| 2 | JE Culff | Normandy v Banstead | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1876 |
| 2 | GCH Barlow | Banstead v Normandy | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1876 |
| 2 | JK Maunders | East Molesey v Sunbury | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1878 |
| 2 | K Smith | East Molesey v Sunbury | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1878 |
| 2 | JME Barrs | Wimbledon v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1879 |
| 2 | OJ Davey | Ashtead v Weybridge | Woodfield Lane, Ashtead | surrp1880 |
| 2 | S Reeves | Ashtead v Weybridge | Woodfield Lane, Ashtead | surrp1880 |
| 2 | F Austin | Cranleigh v Normandy | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1882 |
| 2 | A McCallum | East Molesey v Esher | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1883 |
| 2 | DT Reed | Esher v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1883 |
| 2 | Himmat Singh | Esher v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1883 |
| 2 | Himmat Singh | Normandy v East Molesey | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1885 |
| 2 | A Hughes | Esher v Sunbury | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1887 |
| 2 | K Baumgartner | Esher v Sunbury | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1887 |
| 2 | A Martin | Sunbury v Esher | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1887 |
| 2 | OJ Davey | Banstead v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1888 |
| 2 | Himmat Singh | Reigate Priory v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1892 |
| 2 | JE Culff | Ashtead v Banstead | Recreation Ground, Banstead | surrp1893 |
| 2 | NR Welch | Cranleigh v Wimbledon | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1894 |
| 2 | JR Winslade | East Molesey v Weybridge | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1895 |
| 2 | K Patel | Reigate Priory v Esher | New Road, Esher | surrp1896 |
| 2 | SJD Burgess | Normandy v Sunbury | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1897 |
| 2 | K Baumgartner | Normandy v Sunbury | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1897 |
| 2 | P Mann | Esher v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1901 |
| 2 | H Chapman | Esher v Weybridge | The Cricket Green, Weybridge | surrp1901 |
| 2 | TZ Meyer | Cranleigh v Banstead | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1903 |
| 2 | A Abbas | Cranleigh v Banstead | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1903 |
| 2 | OJD Swann | Esher v Wimbledon | New Road, Esher | surrp1905 |
| 2 | NRD Compton | Normandy v Weybridge | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1906 |
| 2 | R Haughton | Sunbury v Reigate Priory | Park Lane, Reigate | surrp1907 |
| 2 | JE Southgate | Cranleigh v East Molesey | Memorial Cricket Ground, East Molesey | surrp1913 |
| 2 | R Haughton | Ashtead v Reigate Priory | Woodfield Lane, Ashtead | surrp1914 |
| 2 | A Abbas | Normandy v Banstead | Recreation Ground, Banstead | surrp1915 |
| 2 | G Harper | Cranleigh v Esher | The Common, Cranleigh | surrp1916 |
| 2 | JJN Dewes | Weybridge v Wimbledon | Church Road, Wimbledon | surrp1918 |
| 2 | TC Lloyd | Weybridge v Wimbledon | Church Road, Wimbledon | surrp1918 |
| 2 | S Reeves | Wimbledon v Weybridge | Church Road, Wimbledon | surrp1918 |
| 2 | M Harpur | Wimbledon v Sunbury | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1921 |
| 2 | SJD Burgess | Esher v Sunbury | New Road, Esher | surrp1926 |
| 2 | R Soni | Esher v Sunbury | New Road, Esher | surrp1926 |
| 2 | V Venkateswaran | Esher v Normandy | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1927 |
| 2 | MB Lake | Normandy v Esher | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1927 |
| 2 | D Brent | Normandy v Esher | Hunts Hill Road, Normandy | surrp1927 |
| 2 | SDJ Burge | Reigate Priory v East Molesey | Park Lane, Reigate | surrp1928 |
| 2 | C Young | Sunbury v Ashtead | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1929 |
| 2 | SJD Burgess | Ashtead v Sunbury | Kenton Court Meadow, Sunbury-on-Thames | surrp1929 |
| 2 | DCA Newton | Wimbledon v Banstead | Church Road, Wimbledon | surrp1931 |
