| 6 | LR Walters | v Free State | Union Ground, St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 2013/14 | a22937 |
| 5 | DH Howell | v Northern Transvaal | Technikon Oval, Pretoria | 1983/84 | a3974 |
| 5 | DJ Richardson | v Natal | Kingsmead, Durban | 1992/93 | a7924 |
| 5 | G Morgan | v Eastern Transvaal | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1994/95 | a9131 |
| 5 | M Slwana | v Zimbabwe Under-23s | Pollock Field, Grey High School Ground, Port Elizabeth | 2005/06 | a16923 |
| 4 | KS McEwan | v Northern Transvaal | Berea Park, Pretoria | 1973/74 | a1065 |
| 4 | AC Galpin | v Border | Jan Smuts Ground, East London | 1978/79 | a2303 |
| 4 | DJ Richardson | v Border | Buffalo Park, East London | 1988/89 | a5878 |
| 4 | DJ Richardson | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1989/90 | a6464 |
| 4 | DJ Richardson | v Western Province | Newlands, Cape Town | 1991/92 | a7346 |
| 4 | SC Pope | v Griqualand West | Kimberley Country Club, Kimberley | 1994/95 | a9076 |
| 4 | G Morgan | v Western Transvaal | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 1995/96 | a9734 |
| 4 | AM Sodumo | v Border | Buffalo Park, East London | 2006/07 | a17895 |
| 4 | SR Adair | v South Western Districts | Recreation Ground, Oudtshoorn | 2007/08 | a18684 |
| 4 | LR Walters | v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | Axxess DSL St George's, Port Elizabeth | 2012/13 | a22145 |
| 4 | MC Christensen | v KwaZulu-Natal | Chatsworth Stadium, Chatsworth | 2016/17 | a25068 |
| 4 | GL Cloete | v Namibia | Wanderers Cricket Ground, Windhoek | 2016/17 | a25088 |
| 4 | MP Breetzke | v KwaZulu-Natal Inland | St George's Park, Port Elizabeth | 2016/17 | a25220 |
| 4 | S Qeshile | v Gauteng | St George's Park, Gqeberha | 2022/23 | a29771 |
