| Main FC | Middlesex (1877-1880) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1878-1880) |
| | United States of America (1884) |
| Other FC | South of England (1879) |
| | London United Eleven (1879) |
| Miscellaneous | Malvern College (1871-1873) |
| | Hastings (1872-1880) |
| | Middlesex Clubs (1876-1877) |
| | Middlesex Colts (1876) |
| | Surrey Club (1876) |
| | Incogniti (1876) |
| | Mote Park (1876) |
| | St John's Wood (1876) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1877-1880) |
| | Gentlemen of East Sussex (1877) |
| | Kensington Park (1878) |
| | Orleans Club (1879) |
| | Rotherham (1880) |
| | Herefordshire (1881) |
| | Winnipeg (1882) |
| | Western Association (1882) |
| | Pittsburgh (1883-1885) |
| | Picked XI (1884) |
| | Ontario Association (1885) |
| | Newark (USA) (1889-1893) |
| | New York Cricket Club (1890-1900) |
| | New York and District (1893) |
| | Manhattan (1894) |
| | Hoboken (1895) |
| | Roseville (USA) (1897-1898) |
| | Essex County (USA) (1901-1906) |
