Teams Edward Rutter played for
| Main FC | Middlesex (pre county club) (1862) |
| Middlesex (1868-1876) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1869-1874) | |
| Other FC | Southgate (1868) |
| Gentlemen of England (1870-1876) | |
| Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club (1870) | |
| Gentlemen of the South (1870-1871) | |
| Miscellaneous | Rugby School (1860-1861) |
| Fly-by-Nights (1867-1868) | |
| Free Foresters (1867-1881) | |
| Southgate (1868-1876) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1869-1880) | |
| Middlesex (1873-1876) | |
| Veterans Over-40 (1887) |