| Main FC | Cambridge University (1860-1862) |
| | Surrey (1861) |
| | Middlesex (pre county club) (1863) |
| | Middlesex (1867-1868) |
| Other FC | Gentlemen (1861-1862) |
| | Gentlemen of the South (1862-1866) |
| | Southgate (1867) |
| Miscellaneous | Rugby School (1858-1859) |
| | Cambridge University Next XXII (1860) |
| | Cambridge University (1860-1864) |
| | Quidnuncs (1860-1876) |
| | Cambridge University Long Vacation Club (1860-1861) |
| | Surrey (1861-1862) |
| | Oxford and Cambridge Universities (1861) |
| | Surrey Club (1862-1866) |
| | Gentlemen of Middlesex (1864) |
| | Upper Tooting (1866) |
| | Free Foresters (1867-1879) |
| | Southgate (1868) |
| | Will-o'-the-Wisp (1872-1877) |
| | Bar (1875-1876) |
| | Bingley (1878) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1880) |
