Teams Horace Brearley played for
| Main FC | Minor Counties (1937) |
| Yorkshire (1937) | |
| Middlesex (1949) | |
| Minor Counties Championship | Yorkshire Second XI (1935-1937) |
| Middlesex Second XI (1949-1950) | |
| County Championship | Yorkshire (1937) |
| Middlesex (1949) | |
| Miscellaneous | Universities Athletic Union (1934-1937) |
| Minor Counties (1937) | |
| Yorkshire Second XI (1937) | |
| Club Cricket Conference (1946-1947) | |
| The Forty Club (1954-1967) | |
| Brentham (1960-1969) |