| Test | England (1876/77) |
| Main FC | Yorkshire (1872-1878) |
| Other FC | United North of England Eleven (1875-1879) |
| | James Lillywhite's XI (1876/77) |
| | England (1876/77) |
| | Players of United States of America (1886) |
| Miscellaneous | Channel Islands (1869) |
| | Keighley (1870-1877) |
| | Knottingley (1871) |
| | Ilkley (1871) |
| | Colts of England (1873) |
| | Burnley (1873) |
| | Bradford (1874) |
| | Hallam (1875) |
| | Yorkshire United (1875-1876) |
| | Yorkshire (1875-1878) |
| | England XI (1875) |
| | Barrow (1876) |
| | James Lillywhite's XI (1876-1876/77) |
| | United North of England Eleven (1878-1880) |
| | Players of Sheffield (1879) |
| | Hunslet (1880) |
| Scotland Cap | Yorkshire (1878) |
